My dad went to grade
school in a one-room schoolhouse in rural Minnesota. He had to walk a mile
to school, even when it was freezing. One February, so we heard all our
lives, it was so cold that it never got above 20 below. As my little brother
quipped, "It was so bad he had to walk uphill---both ways!" But I would
put dad’s seven years education (seven because he managed to skip the second
grade) in that one-room schoolhouse up against anybody’s grade school education
at the most sophisticated, plugged-in, computer-rich, media-savvy environment.
He learned well.
This little one room
school house had one teacher for all those children. It was cold in the
winter and hot in the late Spring and early Fall. There were no fancy visual
aids per se. No computers, no videos, no recordings. Just books, a dedicated
teacher, and a trusty paddle---if needed. The school day began with prayer
and with the pledge of allegiance. The focus of the education was on the
basics.
The building dad and
his classmates learned in was torn down long ago. But at a family reunion
recently, we were able to see a facsimile of such a school. The one room
schoolhouse from a different township had been saved and refurbished, serving
as a type of museum, providing a glimpse into the past.
Go back the two previous
centuries and we also see a well-educated populace. When I see documentaries
with quotes from ordinary 19th century Americans, I am struck at the level
of education. Someone noted that the reason the essays in The Federalist
Papers by Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay were so sophisticated
was because they were written primarily to reach 18th century American
farmers.
Is it just me---or
are we going backwards in this country when it comes to education? The
phrase "the dumbing down of America" comes to mind.
Just this week a new
study confirmed our suspicions. Bloomberg News reports, "Fifteen-year-old
students in the U.S. ranked 25th of 34 countries on an international math
test and scored in the middle of the pack in science and reading, raising
concerns the U.S. isn’t prepared to succeed in the global economy."
There are obviously
many factors contributing to this regress in our national educational achievements.
These would include:
·the kicking God
out of the schools (as the Bible says, "the fear of the Lord is the beginning
of wisdom"),
·the breakdown of
the family,
·the teachers’ union,
which won’t allow seemingly any discipline over mediocre teachers or worse,
·efforts by groups
like the ACLU that prevent trouble-making students from being kicked out
of schools.
But there’s one huge problem I fault that many might not have considered
(and this gets back to the teachers’ union as well): education today has
largely become affective (focusing on psychology) at the expense of being
effective. There is an over-emphasis on self-esteem and under-emphasis
on core instruction. It doesn’t matter whether little Johnny can read or
write well. All that matters is how little Johnny feels. If you make him
feel bad for not reading or writing well, then shame on you.
We have put so much stress
on the importance of self-esteem that the result is a false and over-inflated
picture of the self. This leads to arrogance and puffed up fluff, without
any real substance to support it. A friend of mine describes a person with
such an attitude as "a prima donna without portfolio."
About ten years ago, columnist
Thomas Sowell reported on another study on the education level of Americans
versus children of other countries. The study found that American students
have higher self-esteem but lower academic achievements simultaneously.
For example, in one international test of 13-year olds, Korean children
ranked first in math and Americans ranked last. Yet 68 percent of the Americans
felt they were "good at mathematics" compared to only 23 percent of the
Korean students Thus, the American youngsters ranked first in self-esteem
and last in actual skills. This is a result of misguided emphasis on boosting
self-esteem without any base in reality.
I have no idea of
the level of the self-esteem of the students in my dad’s one-room school
house. Chances are, it was not too high. But for the most part, when they
graduated, they could read, write, perform basic math functions, and they
had a working knowledge of history, geography, and science.
Why, educational achievements
like that are enough to boost one’s self-esteem.
###