George Orwell wrote
in his classic novel, 1984: "Who controls the past, controls the future:
who controls the present controls the past."
So there’s a battle
over history. That battle continues in our day.
A recent survey finds
that many of our young people are failing to learn basic facts of our nation’s
history. For example, only 35% of 4th-graders know what the purpose of
the Declaration of Independence was.
That’s scary because
if we don’t know where we came from, we don’t know where we are going.
That’s a paraphrase of President Woodrow Wilson.
Our 28th president
said in a rally in 1911 before his election: “A nation which does not remember
what it was yesterday, does not know what it is today, nor what it is trying
to do. We are trying to do a futile thing if we do not know where we came
from or what we have been about...” He went on to speak of America’s spiritual
heritage.
In my opinion, political
correctness lay at the root of the problem. Too often the schools are more
concerned about children’s self-esteem than they are about how much they
learn.
They are taught by-and-large
a multi-cultural approach to the world. The idea, for example, of America
being exceptional is so anathema that it would be unthinkable to teach
today. Meanwhile, thousands of would-be immigrants will literally risk
their lives to try to get to this supposedly non-exceptional nation.
The survey released this
week was conducted by the National Assessment of Educational Progress in
2010---entitled “The Nation’s Report Card: U.S. History 2010.”
They found there has been
little overall progress in the same realm since 2006. The only good news
to the survey seemed to be that there was a slight uptick in the performance
of black and Hispanic students.
The survey found that only
22% of 4th-graders in this country and only 17% of 8th graders were in
the category of “proficient” or “advanced” in their knowledge of U.S. history.
That means 80% or more were not proficient.
They found that more than
half of all high school seniors showed a less-than-basic knowledge about
our history. In fact only 13% of high school seniors have a “solid grasp”
on the subject. Ouch.
In the National Assessment
of Educational Progress’s website, they give these examples of questions
in the “Advanced” category. (Note that generally these appeared in a multiple
choice format):
*Give two reasons why people immigrate to the U.S.
*Explain how machines and factories changed work.
*Identify a photo of President Lincoln and give
two reasons he was important.
Here are examples of questions reflecting a “Proficient” knowledge
in this area:
*Understand why cities grew in certain locations.
*Identify the Cold War communist superpower.
*Use a map to explain the purpose of the Lewis and
Clark expedition.
Finally, here are examples in the “Basic” realm:
*Understand a purpose of the Bill of Rights.
*Identify the change for African Americans after
the Civil War.
*Understand the purpose of a government poster.
In light of the dismal results, I guess it’s true what the old song
says: “Don’t know much about history.”
As noted, I personally suspect
that the liberal agenda is a big part of the problem. Just the other week,
I read about a public school in Arkansas, where the students voted on the
five worst people who ever lived. Two of the results were not surprising:
Adolf Hitler and Charles Manson. But among the five worst human beings
who ever lived, according to these public school students, were George
W. Bush and Dick Cheney!
Wow. If that’s what they
are teaching in Arkansas, I don’t think I want to know about the curriculum
in Massachusetts.
At one time, America was
one of the best educated nations in the world. In New England, after generations
of Puritan influence, John Adams remarked that finding an illiterate man
in New England was as rare as a comet.
The founders understood
that our experiment in self-government could only be maintained by a well-educated
populace. James Madison, one of the key architects of the Constitution,
said in his Second Inaugural Address, “A well-instructed people alone can
be permanently a free people.”
That’s why an accurate grasp
of history matters.
###